Persuasive Writing: The Grade 3 Edition

Grade 3: Anti-bullying

Hey, Little Ant by Phillip and Hannah Hoose

Persuasive Writing

Before Lesson (Pre-Teaching)

·        Students should be familiar with the concepts and people involved in bullying (also need to understand about power imbalance)

·        If you would like to assess this activity, then students should have been exposed to persuasive writing and have completed some activities in which they practiced persuasive writing

·        You may want to use First Steps: “Eat More Fruit” (read aloud/ask: Why was this written? What is this telling you to do?  Has anyone tried to convince/persuade you to do something?  What reasons did they give you?), label the parts of the text (e.g., opinion, reason #1/support, reason #2/support, summary, call for action)

·        Could repeat with “Why you should not smoke” (available upon request) or other examples

·        Prereading: discuss British vocabulary Would you Rather by John Birmingham (Tribes four corners activity put a “choice” in each corner of the room for students to go to) pair/group off students so that students who choose a different answer are together, students would try to convince the others that their choice is the best (may want to have them write this after using graphic organizer—see below)  I used the choices “supper in a castle”, “breakfast in a balloon”, “tea on the river”

More fun for later would you rather ideas:

·        Your house is surrounded by: snow, water, jungle

·        An elephant drank your bath water, an eagle stole your dinner, a pig tried on your clothes, a hippo slept in your bed

·        Covered in jam, soaked with water, pulled through the mud by a dog

·        Spider stew, slug dumplings, mashed worms, drink snail squash

·        Jump in stinging nettles for $10, swallow a dead frog for $40, stay all night in a creepy house for $100

·        Crushed by a snake, swallowed by a fish, eaten by a crocodile, sat on by a rhinoceros

·        Your dad did a dance at your school, your mom has an argument in Tim Horton’s

·        Clash the cymbals, bang the drum, blow the trumpet

·        Have a monkey to tickle, a bear to read to, a cat to box with, a dog to skate with, a pig to ride, a goat to dance with

·        Chased by: a crab, a bull, a lion, wolves

·        Lost in: the fog, in a desert, at sea, in a forest, in a crowd

·        Help: a fairy make magic, gnomes dig for treasure, an imp be naughty, a witch make a stew, Santa Claus deliver presents

·        Live with: a gerbil in a cage, a fish in a bowl, a parrot on a perch, a rabbit in a hutch, chickens in a coop, a dog in a kennel

During Lesson

·        Could use this as an introduction to persuasive writing OR as lesson part way through a persuasive unit

·        Read the book Hey, Little Ant to the class

·        Review “person who is bullied,” “person who is doing the bullying,” and “bystander”

·        Divide the class into 2 groups for a debate, assign a role (ant or boy) to each group

·        Give each group chart paper to record arguments (ideally 1 point/student) to support their position, using information from the text and their own ideas

·        Have the 2 groups sit facing each other in rows

·        The first person from the ant group states an argument (someone from the opposing group can respond)

·        The first person from the boy group states an argument (someone from the opposing group can respond)

·        When everyone has had a chance to participate (or all arguments are exhausted), then students would choose a position to write about, you may wish to have everyone argue the position of the ant to reinforce the message of anti-bullying/environmentalism

·        You may wish to provide a graphic organizer to help students generate ideas/paragraphs

After Lesson (Assessment/Extension)

·        See rubric below for persuasive writing

·        May wish to repeat the same activity with other texts (e.g., Great Kapok Tree)

·        or concepts (e.g., living in medieval times is better than today)

·        Write about other persuasive topics (e.g., walk to school, not smoking, why they should/should not complete homework, wear a school uniform…)

·        May wish to assess a reading response question such as:

Explain a situation similar to this one.

Why are even small creatures important? 

How did the illustrator create interesting or unusual pictures?  Why were they drawn this way?

A Fresh New Look!

Welcome to the newly revised Mr. M's edublog. While it is still under construction we plan on providing educators, parents and student resources and items for all to use. Stay tune as continued changes will be taking place.